President Trump's new executive order tells federal contractors and subcontractors to consult the administration about congressional inquiries, coordinate "appropriate responses," and hold back communications the White House considers privileged. Companies that don't go along risk losing their contracts, according to the Associated Press. That raises an obvious question: if a company stonewalls Congress, what can Congress do about it? Inherent contempt is the oldest answer.

How is inherent contempt different from other kinds of contempt?

Inherent contempt is the only kind Congress carries out entirely by itself. The Congressional Research Service (CRS) describes three types: inherent contempt forces compliance, criminal contempt punishes, and civil contempt gets a court to remove the obstruction. Criminal contempt depends on the Justice Department agreeing to prosecute. Civil contempt depends on a judge. With inherent contempt, the person is tried at the bar of the House or Senate and can be held until they produce the testimony or documents, or until the session ends.

(The quotes and figures here come from the July 2007 edition of the CRS report. An updated version is on congress.gov, and its numbers may differ.)

When has Congress actually used it?

It was used often for well over a century. CRS traces the first use to 1795, when Robert Randall and Charles Whitney allegedly offered three House members money for a law granting Randall's group roughly 18 to 20 million acres along Lake Erie.

Some later cases, as recounted by legal writer Brendon Beebe:

  • 1848: The Senate held journalist John Nugent for refusing to say who leaked him a draft of a secret treaty. He kept filing stories, datelined "Custody of the Sergeant-at-Arms."
  • 1860: The Senate jailed abolitionist Thaddeus Hyatt for about 90 days during its inquiry into Harper's Ferry.
  • 1876: The House jailed speculator Hallet Kilbourn for 45 days. While held, he ran up a $488 catering bill.
  • 1934: During the Air Mail scandal, the Senate tried former Assistant Commerce Secretary William MacCracken Jr. on its floor for letting associates remove and destroy subpoenaed papers. He served a 10-day sentence under guard in a room at the Willard Hotel. He's described as the last person Congress itself actually locked up.

Congress passed a criminal contempt law in 1857, partly because inherent contempt fell short. Even so, a study cited by CRS found that from 1857 to 1934 Congress relied almost entirely on inherent contempt anyway.

The threat alone often did the job. A study CRS cites found at least 28 cases where witnesses threatened with or charged with contempt cleared themselves by testifying or turning over documents.

What has the Supreme Court said about it?

The Court has upheld the power several times but has also put limits on it. The key cases:

Why hasn't Congress used it since the 1930s?

It's awkward and slow. CRS notes that it has been called "unseemly," cumbersome, time-consuming, and relatively ineffective for a busy modern Congress, and says neither chamber has used it since 1935.

You'll see both 1934 and 1935 given as the date of the last use. Both are correct, depending on what you count. MacCracken was tried and held in 1934, and the Supreme Court upheld that in 1935.

There's also a practical problem: Congress has no jail. The House Historian's Office says no Capitol room was ever formally a jail. Past detainees were held in the Sergeant-at-Arms' office, in committee rooms, in local hotels, or in the D.C. jail. Nobody knows who would make an arrest today or where the person would be held.

Has anyone tried to bring it back?

Yes, several times. CRS notes that most precedents involved locking people up, but there may be an argument for monetary fines instead.

Could Congress use it against a federal contractor?

Nobody knows yet, but contractors look more like the classic targets than cabinet officers do. Every modern debate has been about executive-branch officials. Yet several of the historical cases above involved private people: the 1795 land speculators, a journalist, an abolitionist, a speculator, and a banker.

The main legal argument against using inherent contempt in a privilege fight comes from the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel (OLC). In 1986, as described by CRS, OLC said it "seems unlikely" Congress would send the Sergeant-at-Arms to arrest an executive official who was asserting executive privilege. OLC argued that its 1984 reasoning against prosecuting such officials applies to inherent contempt too.

That reasoning was written about government officials carrying out a presidential privilege claim. Whether it protects a private company that the White House has told to treat its communications as privileged is an open question.

Congress may also have a simpler route against companies. The Senate's 1979 civil-enforcement law, which lets the Senate ask a court to enforce its subpoenas, doesn't cover federal officers acting in their official capacity, so it applies to others, including private parties. CRS counted at least six uses through 1995, none of them against executive officials. That gives Congress a court option against contractors that it doesn't have against officials. One limit: the law belongs to the Senate, not the House.

Can Congress force contractors to answer right now?

Not the Democrats. They take over Congress in January and have named government contracts as a top investigative target, including Pentagon money going to companies linked to Trump's family. White House counsel Will Scharf pointed out that Democrats aren't in the majority yet and can't compel compliance.

So any contempt fight over contractors is still in the future. It isn't clear whether the new majority will subpoena contractors at all. If it does, it could start with criminal referrals, which a Trump Justice Department may not prosecute, or with civil lawsuits before reaching for a power Congress hasn't used in about 90 years.