That's why the new order doesn't try to block congressional subpoenas outright. It works on the contractor's side instead. The White House fact sheet says contractors and subcontractors must tell the White House and their agencies about congressional requests, coordinate their responses, and follow White House instructions on withholding anything it considers privileged. According to AP, companies that don't comply could lose their contracts and be suspended from future federal work.
So the real question isn't whether Congress can subpoena a contractor. It's what happens to a company that gets one.
Where does Congress's power over private companies come from?
It comes from a 1927 Supreme Court case about a private banker. In McGrain v. Daugherty, a Senate committee investigating Attorney General Harry Daugherty subpoenaed his brother Mally, president of an Ohio bank, to testify and bring documents. Mally Daugherty refused to appear and was arrested. The Court held for the first time that Congress's power to compel witnesses is part of its constitutional power to legislate.
The Court also traced the practice back much further, to 1792, when the House gave a select committee investigating the St. Clair expedition authority to send for "persons, papers and records" (Wikipedia).
The power has one main limit. Congress has no "general" power to dig into private affairs. It can investigate only in support of its lawmaking role (Wikipedia).
Does the order stop Congress from getting contractors' records?
Not legally, and the White House's own reasoning doesn't say it does. The fact sheet argues that Congress can't seek contractors' information "without a valid legislative purpose" or in ways that intrude on core executive functions or privileged material. That accepts the basic power and argues only about where its edges are.
What the order adds is pressure. Writing a week before it was signed, the law firm Holland & Knight predicted that agencies might tell contractors to send productions through the agency, hold back or redact documents, or stall. It warned that a company could end up stuck between a committee demanding compliance and an agency demanding restraint. The order turns that prediction into formal policy, with the contract itself at stake.
Whether the government can lawfully cancel a contract because a company obeyed a valid subpoena is an open question.
Can the White House claim executive privilege over a contractor's files?
It can try, but no one knows how far that claim reaches. AP notes that executive privilege protects confidential White House deliberations but is "far from absolute," and that fights over it can drag on in court for a long time (CBS News/AP).
Subpoenas to outside firms that hold records about the president aren't new, though. In Trump v. Mazars (2020), House committees subpoenaed banks and Trump's personal accounting firm. In that case the president argued the subpoenas lacked a legislative purpose. He didn't claim executive privilege. The Supreme Court created a four-factor test for subpoenas seeking a president's personal information. Courts ask whether the purpose justifies involving the president, whether the subpoena is no broader than reasonably necessary, what evidence Congress offers, and how much it burdens the president.
It's unclear whether courts would apply that stricter test to a contractor's dealings with agencies, as opposed to the president personally.
Congress also has its own view of privilege. Holland & Knight notes that Congress has historically said it isn't bound by common-law protections such as attorney-client privilege, and that committees rule on privilege claims themselves.
What happens if a contractor refuses a subpoena?
Congress has three enforcement tools, and the most familiar one runs through the executive branch.
- Criminal contempt. Willfully defying a committee subpoena is a misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in prison (CRS). But once a chamber refers a contempt citation, any prosecution "lies within the control of the executive branch" (CRS). Here that means a Justice Department run by the same administration that issued the order.
- Civil enforcement. A chamber can ask a federal court to order compliance. The Senate has a statute for this. It doesn't apply to federal officials acting in their official capacity (CRS), so it can reach private companies. In 2016 the Senate used it to go to court over a subpoena to Backpage.com's CEO (Levin Center). The House has no matching statute but has brought civil suits under authorizing resolutions (CRS).
- Inherent contempt. Congress can have its Sergeant-at-Arms take a witness into custody, as the Senate did with Daugherty. Neither chamber has used this power since 1935 (CRS).
Congressional subpoenas also aren't governed by the federal rules for ordinary lawsuits. Courts give committees wide latitude, and refusing can lead to public hearings as well as legal action (Holland & Knight).
When can Democrats actually start issuing subpoenas?
Not until they hold the majority in the new Congress. Democrats won both chambers in the 2026 midterms (Holland & Knight). Until they take over, minority letters can't force anyone to do anything. White House Counsel Will Scharf made exactly that point when he dismissed document-preservation letters from Rep. Robert Garcia (CBS News/AP).
Incoming chairs are already setting deadlines. Sen. Richard Blumenthal warned that failing to produce information by January 4, 2027, could bring compulsory measures, and Rep. Adam Smith promised to restore an oversight subcommittee on contracts awarded to private companies (Holland & Knight). The same firm expects early targets to include no-bid and sole-source awards. Examples are the White House ballroom, reportedly built under a no-bid contract worth up to $500 million, and urgent munitions and drone contracts tied to the Iran conflict.
Can contractor employees still go to Congress on their own?
Federal law says yes. Disclosures by contractor employees to members of Congress and committees are expressly protected under whistleblower laws, 10 U.S.C. § 4701 and 41 U.S.C. § 4712 (Holland & Knight). The White House fact sheet doesn't say how the order fits with those laws.
What isn't known yet?
The order's full text hasn't been widely reported. Most coverage, including this article, relies on the fact sheet. So details like how the rules would be written into contract clauses, or any deadlines, aren't public. It's also unknown whether courts would allow the government to end contracts over subpoena compliance, and whether the new majorities would prefer civil suits to contempt referrals that the Justice Department may never prosecute.