The Shenzhen meeting on Nov. 19 was the first-ever three-way summit of Trump, Xi and Putin, and the first leader-level arms control talks since New START expired. It ran a little over an hour and ended without an arms control agreement. So the gap the treaty left in February is still there.
What limits on US and Russian nuclear weapons still exist?
Only an informal one: Russia's promise, with nothing to enforce it. In September 2025, Putin proposed that both sides keep informally observing the treaty's central limits for one year. Trump first called it a "good idea." But on Feb. 4, Russia's foreign ministry confirmed that Washington had never formally replied.
A week after the treaty lapsed, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov told Russia's parliament that the moratorium on going over the old limits was still in force, but only as long as the US stays under them too.
There was also talk of a separate arrangement. Axios reported that US and Russian representatives meeting in Abu Dhabi discussed a possible six-month informal understanding to stick to the treaty and restart talks. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov confirmed the talks happened. US officials did not.
On the US side, Trump posted on Feb. 5 that the country would seek a "new, improved, and modernized Treaty" instead. No such treaty exists yet.
How would anyone know if the limits were broken?
Mostly they wouldn't, at least not publicly. Checking on New START had broken down years before it expired. On-site inspections stopped in March 2020, and Russia suspended its participation in February 2023. The treaty had also already been extended for the five years it allowed, the maximum, so it couldn't be extended again.
Putin's freeze offer didn't fill that hole either. As analyst Amy Woolf pointed out, it did not include restarting the data exchanges and notifications Russia suspended in 2023. That leaves each government to judge the other's compliance with its own intelligence. We found no public US assessment of whether Russia has stayed under the old caps, or the reverse.
What did the Shenzhen summit actually agree to?
It produced a statement, not a treaty. According to the White House, the three leaders said a nuclear war "cannot be won and must never be fought" and agreed to hold dialogues on nonproliferation and reducing nuclear risk. Xi proposed regular high-level exchanges and a three-way crisis communication channel.
The "never be fought" line isn't new. In early 2022 the US, Russia, China, France and the UK reaffirmed that 1985 Reagan-Gorbachev principle.
Nobody has said yet who will attend the promised dialogues or when they start, and there's no word on whether Xi's crisis channel will actually be built.
Why isn't China bound by any of this?
China was never part of New START, and it has refused to join any limits. Every major strategic arms reduction treaty so far has been between just two countries, the US and Russia.
Beijing's argument is about size. China has more than 600 nuclear warheads, while the US and Russia each have more than 5,000. SIPRI estimates that the US and Russia together hold about 86% of all nuclear warheads. The day after the treaty expired, China's disarmament ambassador Shen Jian said China would not join nuclear disarmament talks "at this stage". He said the two bigger powers have to cut first and urged Washington to accept Russia's freeze offer.
Chinese analysts quoted by Al Jazeera give three more reasons. A treaty would cap China's small "insurance" force and subject it to intrusive inspections. China doesn't trust US commitments after Washington left the ABM and INF treaties. And US missile defenses and precision weapons could threaten China's ability to strike back.
China's arsenal is small but growing quickly. SIPRI puts it at about 620 warheads, with roughly 100 added each year since 2023, the fastest growth of any country. The Pentagon expects China to reach 1,000 by 2030. Beijing doesn't publish its plans, so it's unclear whether it wants to match the US and Russia or stop short.
Does the US want a deal with Russia alone, or one that includes China?
Officials have said different things. In a January interview with The New York Times, Trump said he would do a deal with Russia without China. In February, Secretary of State Marco Rubio said real arms control is impossible without China, and Under Secretary Thomas DiNanno called a deal with only one other nuclear power "simply inappropriate in 2026".
DiNanno also set a high bar for any new treaty. Speaking in Geneva, he said it would have to cover all of Russia's nuclear weapons, including the shorter-range tactical ones where Russia has a numerical lead, plus the "breakout growth" of China's stockpile. Days later, an assistant secretary said the US had proposed multilateral talks on strategic stability.
Trying to bring China in has failed before. The first Trump administration tried it, and the effort collapsed in 2020. US-China nuclear talks held in November 2023 didn't continue.
Moscow has demands of its own. Some Russian voices want British and French nuclear weapons counted on the Western side.
Could the US or Russia add nuclear weapons quickly?
Yes, to some degree. With the treaty gone, the US is free to go past 1,550 deployed strategic warheads and 700 deployed launchers. Belfer Center analysts list the quickest options as loading more warheads onto existing missiles, reopening launch tubes on Ohio-class submarines, and assigning more bombers to nuclear missions. DiNanno said the US keeps non-deployed nuclear capacity it could use if the president directs. The US hasn't said whether it will do any of this.
Russia could add more too. Analyst Nicole Grajewski expects Moscow to keep its deployed forces near the old ceilings for now, holding spare warhead capacity on missiles like the RS-24 Yars and Sarmat in reserve. She says Russia is limited more by missiles and other delivery systems than by warheads.
That spare capacity is why former New START negotiator Rose Gottemoeller warned senators in February that Russia could outpace the US in adding warheads if Washington ignored the freeze offer and began building up.
Is a new arms race likely?
Experts disagree. Gary Samore expects Putin would probably accept a two-country replacement treaty. But because Trump wants China included and China won't join without equal standing, he sees a nuclear buildup as the most likely path. Grajewski's outlook, in the same Belfer roundup, is slower and more cautious, with Russia holding near its old levels.
What should we watch for next?
Watch three things:
- Russia's freeze. On Putin's original terms it ran for one year, which would put its end around February 2027. Moscow hasn't said whether it will extend the pledge or drop it sooner in response to US moves.
- The Shenzhen dialogues. Whether the promised talks meet, and who attends, will show whether the summit statement leads to anything.
- Smaller safety steps. Short of a treaty, Woolf has proposed a two-track US-Russia-China process. Leaders would agree on broad principles, and experts would work on practical steps like launch notifications and communication links. Xi's crisis channel idea fits that second track, if it gets built.