When Prime Minister Mark Carney said in China that Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if talks with Trump fail to keep North America's auto industry integrated, those "talks" were taking place under CUSMA, a deal now in its annual-review stage. Coverage of the trip mostly skips how that process works, and some explainers were written before the July 1 outcome. Here is where things stand.
What is the joint review, exactly?
It's a built-in check-up. CUSMA (called USMCA in the US) came into force on July 1, 2020, replacing NAFTA, and the treaty required a first joint review on its sixth anniversary, July 1, 2026. Global Affairs Canada calls the review "not an expiry date" and describes it as a scheduled check-in.
At the review, the three countries had two options under Article 34.7. They could extend the deal another 16 years, to 2042, or fall into annual reviews until it expires in 2036. One caution: the government's explainer page was last updated before the July 1 meeting, so it still describes the review as something coming up.
What happened on July 1, 2026?
The US said no to renewal. At a Free Trade Commission meeting held online, US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer said the US "did not agree to renew the USMCA in its current form." Canada and Mexico both confirmed that they supported a 16-year extension, so Washington was the only holdout. A month earlier, Canada's Minister Dominic LeBlanc had sent a letter to Greer and Mexico's Marcelo Ebrard signalling Canada's support for renewal.
Does that mean CUSMA has lapsed?
No. Headlines saying the deal "is not renewed" can give that impression, but all CUSMA rights stay in effect, including preferential tariffs, rules of origin, investment protections and dispute settlement. LeBlanc had described this outcome back in February: without consensus, he said, "the agreement continues on" and an annual review begins.
How do the annual reviews work?
Non-renewal triggers Article 34.7.4, which means joint reviews every year until July 1, 2036. At any point before then, the countries can still extend the deal for 16 years if their heads of government confirm it in writing. No formal renegotiation is required. If nobody acts by 2036, the agreement expires.
Before July 1, analysts treated this as one of three possible outcomes. Eurasia Group called it the "zombie USMCA" and ranked it ninth among its top 10 risks for 2026. The deal stays alive, but every year it could become a bargaining chip again.
The date and agenda of the first annual review, due on or before July 1, 2027, haven't been published. Nobody has said publicly what the US would need in order to agree to an extension.
What does the US want from Canada?
The US has a list of grievances. Complaints aimed at Canada include dairy supply management, the Online Streaming Act, the Online News Act and provincial bans on US alcohol. Complaints aimed at both Canada and Mexico cover auto rules of origin, Chinese investment and supply-chain exposure, and critical minerals.
Relations have been rocky. Canada-US talks broke down in October 2025 and didn't resume until March 2026. In April testimony to Congress, Greer accused Canada of "doubling down on globalization." Washington is also negotiating with each country separately, and Mexico is further along. The US and Mexico held negotiating rounds in May and June 2026, while Canada had not begun substantive text-based negotiations as of July. Public sources don't confirm whether that has changed since.
Where do the steel, aluminum and auto tariffs fit in?
They sit outside the review entirely. The US sectoral tariffs on steel, aluminum, autos and lumber were imposed under Section 232 of US trade law, and they continue regardless of what happens to CUSMA. LeBlanc said after the July 1 meeting that Canada's priority is those sectoral tariffs.
Could the US just pull out?
Yes. Separately from the review, Article 34.6 lets any country withdraw at any time on six months' written notice. There's a precedent: during the 2018 renegotiation, Trump threatened to trigger NAFTA's withdrawal clause but never did. Whether the US will use the withdrawal threat as leverage this time isn't known.
If the US did withdraw, CUSMA would stay in force between Canada and Mexico. Canada would lose the CUSMA-compliance carve-out that currently exempts about 89% of its exports from US tariffs.
Would the old Canada-US free trade deal come back?
It depends on who you ask. The 1989 Canada-US Free Trade Agreement was suspended, not terminated. Canada's position is that it could revive if CUSMA ends. The US Congressional Research Service says revival wouldn't be automatic and would need a presidential proclamation.
How much is at stake for Canada?
A lot. Canada and the US traded nearly $3.5 billion in goods and services every day in 2025. Comparing 2025 with 2019, Canada-US trade has grown more than 27% since CUSMA took effect.
Forecasts give a sense of the downside if the deal ended:
- Scotiabank modelled CUSMA ending in March 2026. With a 10% US tariff on goods that are now exempt, Canada's real GDP falls 0.6% within a year and unemployment rises to 6.5%. With 35% tariffs, GDP falls 1.9% and unemployment reaches 7.1%.
- Ontario's 2026 budget includes a downside case of US withdrawal plus 12% tariffs, in which provincial growth drops from 1.0% to 0.3% in 2026. 81% of Ontario's goods exports go to the US.
Those numbers model the deal ending, not the limbo Canada is actually in. The cost of years of annual reviews is the least-modelled scenario, and forecasts disagree.
How does the China auto threat play into this?
It touches one of the review's sore points. "Chinese investment and supply-chain exposure" is already on the US list of complaints, so bringing in Chinese automakers would press directly on an issue Washington has raised. How the US would respond is unknown. Carney presented it as a fallback if talks fail to keep an integrated North American auto industry, not as a plan already in motion.