Anthropic's debut is close to a textbook example. It priced at $83 a share, above its marketed range of $70 to $78, and then opened at $111.50, 34% above the IPO price. A gap like this isn't a fluke.

19%: the average first-day gain, though the typical one is much smaller

The best long-run data comes from University of Florida finance professor Jay Ritter. He tracked 9,345 US operating-company IPOs from 1980 to 2025. Measured from the offer price to the first day's close, the mean return was 19.0%. The median was only 7.0%.

A handful of huge winners pull the average up, so the "typical" pop is much smaller than the headline figure suggests.

The pattern isn't new, either. Ritter's tables show average first-day returns of 17.8% in 1960 and 55.9% in 1968, with negative years mixed in.

50%: the average pop when a deal prices above its range

A strong predictor of a big first day is where the final price lands compared with the range the company first filed. From 1980 to 2025, IPOs priced above their filing range averaged a 50% first-day return. Deals priced within the range averaged 12%, and those priced below it averaged 3%. Only about 23% of IPOs priced above their range over that period.

Researchers call this "partial adjustment." When the banks running a deal see strong demand, they raise the price, but not all the way. Finance professor Kathleen Hanley documented this in 1993, and her finding is often read as compensation to bidders for revealing positive information that pushed the price higher.

Anthropic shows every sign of a hot book. Fortune reported that it raised its share count to 980 million from 825 million because of demand, and that underwriters said the deal was as much as seven times oversubscribed. Even so, the price went only about $5 above the top of the range.

1986: when economists started explaining the discount as deliberate

Some personal-finance explainers frame a pop as a mistake. SoFi, for example, calls it a possible sign that underwriters didn't properly price in investor demand. The academic view is that the discount is mostly built in on purpose. Researchers have offered two main explanations:

$250 billion: what IPOs have left on the table

Ritter calls the first-day gain "money left on the table." He calculates it as the first-day closing price minus the offer price, multiplied by the shares sold. From 1980 to 2025, IPOs left a total of $250.1 billion on the table on $1,200 billion raised. In 2025 alone, 90 IPOs left $13.11 billion on the table on $38.97 billion raised.

That money doesn't go to the company. It goes to whoever got shares at the offer price. Anyone buying at the open is paying the popped price. For Anthropic, only about half of institutional orders were filled, and about 20% of shares were set aside for retail investors through brokers including E*Trade, Schwab, SoFi and Fidelity.

Here's a rough sense of scale, using our own arithmetic rather than a sourced figure. At the $111.50 opening price, Anthropic's gap would be about $28.50 a share across 980 million shares, or roughly $27.9 billion. That's about twice what all 2025 IPOs left on the table combined. The real number depends on the closing price.

16.5%: the share of IPOs that close below their offer price

Not every IPO pops. From 1980 to 2025, 16.5% closed below the offer price on day one and 13.0% closed exactly at it. In 2023, a weak year, 53.7% closed below.

The market mood matters a lot. The average first-day return was 71.2% in 1999 and 56.3% in 2000 during the dot-com boom. It was 41.6% in 2020 and just 3.7% in 1984.

0: the offer price in a direct listing

One way to avoid a pop is to skip the offer price altogether. In a direct listing, no shares change hands at a reference price, so Ritter measures those first-day returns from open to close instead. That's one reason direct listings are said to avoid the pop that IPOs hand to the investors who get allocations.

What isn't known yet about Anthropic

The figure researchers compare is the offer-to-close return, and Anthropic's official first-day close hadn't been confirmed when this was written. The stock rose as high as $114.99 and was hovering near $100 about half an hour after trading began.

It also wasn't confirmed whether underwriters would use their option to sell extra shares. If they do, Fortune says proceeds could reach $91.6 billion.