After one weekend, Ebenezer has earned less than half of the 2.5x figure, and that figure probably understates what it needs. To see why the opening was called "modest," you need three numbers the headlines skip: how much of each ticket goes back to the studio, how much the marketing cost, and how reliable the 2.5x rule is.
2.5x: a rule everyone repeats and no one sources
The rule says a film needs to gross about 2.5 times its production budget. Variety's opening-weekend explainer gives it as the industry rule of thumb for getting a movie out of the red. DFI Rentals and Geek Vibes Nation give the same multiplier for a wide release.
The explainers don't agree on what it measures, though. Vitrina states it as a domestic gross threshold, while most others apply it to worldwide gross. That's a big difference. For a film earning half its money overseas, a domestic target is roughly double a worldwide one. None of these pages shows where the 2.5 comes from. The best way to check it is to look at what theaters actually pay studios.
About 50%: the share theaters pay studios
Theater chains report this split to the SEC every year. In its 2025 annual report, AMC puts its film exhibition costs, meaning what it pays distributors, at roughly half of admissions revenue. The filing gives figures of about 48% and 51% in different places, which probably cover different parts of the business. The same report says AMC's seven largest studio distributors supplied about 83% of its U.S. admissions.
Cinemark reports film rentals and advertising at 58.0% of admissions revenue in 2025. That number includes advertising, so the film rental share alone is lower.
The split also varies by film and by country. In Deadline's profit analysis of Avatar: The Way of Water, sources put the studio's share at 65% of the domestic gross, about 55% elsewhere, and 25% in China.
So the core of the rule holds: a studio gets back roughly half of each ticket dollar. The 2.5 multiplier then assumes marketing costs some fixed share of the budget. Ebenezer is where that assumption breaks.
$88 million: Ebenezer's real cost, not $38 million
Before release, Variety reported that Paramount spent $38 million to produce Ebenezer and another $50 million to market it. That marketing number comes from Variety's reporting. The studio hasn't confirmed it.
When a "budget" is quoted, it usually means only the production cost. Geek Vibes also notes there's no set ratio between marketing and production, and that a small film's marketing can equal or exceed what it cost to make. Ebenezer fits that pattern: its marketing reportedly cost more than the movie itself.
Here's the problem with that. At 2.5x, or $95 million worldwide, and a studio share of 40–50%, Paramount would get back about $38–48 million from theaters. That roughly covers production and leaves almost nothing for the $50 million marketing bill.
$175–220 million: a theater-only estimate
This is our own rough calculation, not a figure from Paramount or any outlet. Assume the studio keeps about 50% of the domestic gross and about 40% overseas. Covering $88 million from theaters alone would then take:
- About $176 million if every dollar came from North America
- About $220 million if every dollar came from overseas
- About $198 million at the mix of the opening weekend, which was 45% domestic and 55% overseas
That's 4.6 to 5.8 times the production budget, about double the 2.5x shortcut. The real terms could change it in either direction. Paramount hasn't published its theater splits, overseas deals, profit participations or ancillary contracts.
A film doesn't have to make all of that back in theaters, though. Variety notes that many films eventually break even through ancillary revenue over the years: streaming, digital rental, home video and TV licensing. Nobody knows yet how much Ebenezer will earn from those, including on Paramount's own streaming service, Paramount+.
3% vs. 85%: does the 2.5x line mean anything?
Yes. It turns out to be a fairly sharp dividing line, at least for investors. Researcher Stephen Follows looked at almost a billion dollars invested across several major films. Where a film grossed under 2.5 times its budget, investors were repaid in 3% of cases; above it, 85%.
His other findings show how little of the box office reaches the people who paid for a film. Across that money, investors got back $0.77 for every dollar they put in, and only about 5 cents of each box-office dollar reached them. In one slate of almost 100 films, the top five earned 42% of the money while the bottom 49 earned 6% combined. Most of the money comes from a few big hits, so a middling result usually doesn't pay off.
Keep in mind that Follows measured whether investors got paid back, which isn't the same as a studio's break-even. A studio that owns its film and its streaming service sees different numbers.
$42 million: where Ebenezer stands after one weekend
Ebenezer opened with about $19 million from 3,535 North American theaters and $23 million overseas, for $42 million worldwide. Pre-release tracking had expected about $20 million in each market, so the film came in a little under at home and a little over abroad.
IndieWire argues that the $38 million budget is low enough that the film will turn a profit if audiences keep coming through the holidays and it holds up overseas. After one weekend, it's past 40% of the 2.5x target and about 20% of the theater-only estimate. Most of the money will have to come from the weeks still ahead, and from whatever streaming and TV bring in later.