President Trump says a new 20% federal film and TV incentive would pay for itself, with the money "made up tenfold" by revenue flowing into the Treasury, according to Deadline. States have run film credits for years, and their own auditors have checked whether that kind of claim holds up. Here's what those audits found, and why other studies come up with such different numbers.
34 cents: the average return across state evaluations
New Mexico's Legislative Finance Committee reviewed 13 state film-incentive evaluations from 2014 to 2022. It found an average fiscal return of 34 cents per dollar, ranging from 6 cents to $1.03. Only that top figure clears break-even, and the document doesn't name the state in the passages we reviewed.
Results from individual states fall in the same range:
- New York: the state tax department found about 15 cents in direct tax revenue per dollar, or 31 cents once support jobs are counted. It called the credit break-even at best and more likely a net cost.
- Maryland: the state's legislative services department found a 10-cent return in 2015.
- Massachusetts: a state revenue department study found the state got back 16 cents per credit dollar in 2008.
Kennesaw State economist J.C. Bradbury's 2018 study put the average across the analyses he surveyed at 27 cents per dollar.
$8.40 vs. 34 cents: why industry numbers look so different
The two sides are measuring different things. New Mexico's analysts separate fiscal ROI, the return to taxpayers, from economic ROI, the return to those who benefit from the subsidized activity.
Economic ROI counts all the spending connected to a production: crew wages, hotel stays, catering, equipment rentals. That figure can easily top a dollar. New Mexico's film office advertised an $8.40 economic ROI, and the committee warned that the number could lead readers to wrongly assume the state collected more in taxes than it spent.
Fiscal ROI asks a narrower question: of the dollar the state gave up, how much came back as tax revenue? That's the question behind "pays for itself," and it's the one the audits answer.
The federal debate has the same split. Deadline reported that supporters have released their own studies emphasizing economic activity.
94 cents: even friendly studies usually come in under $1
Even studies paid for by the credits' backers rarely show a full return. New Mexico has three studies of its own credit, each commissioned by a different party:
- 14 cents per dollar (NMSU's Arrowhead Center, for the legislature, 2008)
- 94 cents (Ernst & Young, for the film office and state investment council, 2009)
- 33 cents (MNP LLP, for the economic development department, 2014)
In Louisiana, a consultant hired by the state's own economic development agency found the motion picture credit returned about 22 to 23 cents in state revenue per dollar, or 35 to 39 cents counting local taxes too, in fiscal 2021 and 2022.
Economist Robert Tannenwald of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a group that opposes the credits, found that studies commissioned by film agencies or the MPAA claiming the credits pay for themselves tend to have serious flaws. His analysis is older: it dates from a time when 43 states offered film subsidies.
10 cents or 21: state-only vs. state-plus-local
Many articles quote a single number without saying whose revenue it counts, and the difference is large. Georgia's January 2020 audit found the state got back 10 cents per credit dollar in 2016, with local governments collecting another 11 cents. Depending on which figure you quote, the same credit returned either 10 cents or 21.
Governing cites a 19-cent figure for Georgia, which comes from a later audit using a different year. Either way, the 2020 audit estimated that Georgia's $667 million in 2016 credits led to a net state revenue loss of about $602 million, or about $65,950 per job.
3.57: how assumptions can inflate the benefits
Georgia's audit found that the state's economic development department had used a 3.57 output multiplier for more than 30 years with no clear source. Auditors estimated the film industry's real multiplier at 1.84 and said the department's figure nearly doubled the credit's reported impact.
The audits make generous assumptions too. Georgia's auditors assumed no credited production would have happened without the credit, even though they identified projects that would have filmed in Georgia anyway. They said their estimate therefore probably overstates the credit's impact.
Some of the money also leaves the state. In 2016, 53% of wages tied to Georgia's credit went to nonresidents, and nonresident labor accounted for $245 million of the credits.
$22,800 per job: how film compares with other incentives
In fiscal 2022, New Mexico's film credit cost $22,800 per job, 107% more than the state's LEDA and JTIP job programs. Those programs cost about $9,600 and $12,300 per job, and LEDA's fiscal return was put at $2.60 per dollar. Massachusetts, in its 2008 study, lost $88,000 in revenue for each new job filled by a resident.
The broader research is no kinder. A 2019 NBER working paper by Patrick Button found that incentives affect where productions film but have no meaningful effect on film-industry employment, wages, or establishments. Bradbury found no link between film incentives and state economic performance. Reinvent Albany, which collected these studies, campaigns against the credits.
19 states: why the credits keep spreading anyway
Governing counted at least 19 states that created or expanded film credits from 2021 onward, even as audits found the credits lose money. Some put limits on them: in 2022, Kentucky capped its program at $75 million and Maryland at $20 million. Georgia went the other way. Its credit grew from about $407 million in 2013 to $915 million in 2017, while 27 of the 31 other states with film incentives capped theirs.
$33 billion to $49 billion: what this means for the federal bill
The Cato Institute estimated the federal bill would cost $33 billion to $49 billion. As of Nov. 13, Congress's Joint Committee on Taxation hadn't released its official estimate.
No state audit in this research found anything close to the tenfold return Trump described. The best result in the New Mexico review was $1.03, and most states got back well under half their money.
A federal credit isn't quite the same as a state one, though. State audits measure states taking production from each other. A federal credit is meant to bring work back from other countries. The state record shows how often "it pays for itself" has failed to hold up, but it can't settle the federal question.